Optimal Coupling Conditions for CO2-Reinforced Recycled Coarse Aggregate Based on Response Surface Method

CAO Fu-bo, SU Yu-tong, WANG Chen-xia, HAN Hui-chao, SU Tian

Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2025, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (12) : 151-159.

PDF(7949 KB)
PDF(7949 KB)
Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2025, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (12) : 151-159. DOI: 10.11988/ckyyb.20241109
Hydraulic Structure and Material

Optimal Coupling Conditions for CO2-Reinforced Recycled Coarse Aggregate Based on Response Surface Method

Author information +
History +

Abstract

[Objective] This study aims to optimize the coupling conditions for CO2 reinforcement of recycled coarse aggregate (RCA) by investigating the interactions of three key factors—CO2 concentration, carbonation temperature, and relative humidity—using response surface methodology (RSM). The innovation lies in using a systematic RSM-based approach to model and optimize the carbonation process, overcoming the limitations of traditional methods by capturing complex inter-factor interactions. This provides a more efficient and reliable framework for enhancing RCA performance in sustainable construction applications. [Methods] A Box-Behnken design using Design-Expert software was applied, encompassing 17 sets of carbonation tests to evaluate the effects of CO2 concentration (20%-60%), carbonation temperature (20-60℃), and relative humidity (35%-65%). RCA was derived from waste concrete blocks in Baotou, China, and characterized in accordance with GB/T 25177-2010, with particle sizes between 4.75 and 31.5 mm. The measured responses included crush value (indicator of mechanical strength), water absorption (indicator of porosity), and apparent density (indicator of compactness). Carbonation experiments were performed in a controlled environment, and the obtained data were utilized to develop quadratic regression models using RSM. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted to assess the significance, reliability, and interactions of the models, using evaluation criteria including F-statistic, p-value, coefficient of determination (R2), adjusted R2, predicted R2, coefficient of variation (CV), and signal-to-noise ratio (Adeq Precision). Optimization was performed using the numerical module of Design-Expert to determine the optimal carbonation conditions, which were validated experimentally to confirm model accuracy. [Results] The interaction between carbonation temperature and relative humidity had the strongest effect (p>0.05 for BC interaction), followed by the CO2 concentration-temperature (AB) and CO2 concentration-relative humidity (AC) interactions. The CO2 concentration-temperature (AB) interaction was the most significant, resulting in a parabolic response. Water absorption initially decreased with increasing CO2 concentration and temperature, but increased under extreme conditions due to reduced CO2 diffusion and calcium ion dissolution. The CO2 concentration-relative humidity (AC) interaction was the most significant, making apparent density peak under moderate conditions (e.g., 42% CO2 concentration and 44 ℃) and decline at extremes due to moisture-induced calcium loss or CO2 saturation. The optimization process determined the optimal carbonation conditions as 38% CO2 concentration, 41 ℃ carbonation temperature, and 49% relative humidity. Under these conditions, the predicted values were 14.3% for crush value, 3.80% for water absorption, and 2 700 kg/m3 for apparent density. Experimental validation produced measured values of 14.6% (crush value), 3.85% (water absorption), and 2 702 kg/m3 (apparent density), with relative errors of 2.1%, 1.3%, and 0.1%, respectively. All relative errors were below 5%, confirming model accuracy. Compared with untreated RCA, the optimized carbonation treatment reduced crush value by 18.0%, decreased water absorption by 20.5%, and increased apparent density by 0.9%, demonstrating practical effectiveness. Response surface diagrams and contour plots illustrated these interactions. For example, the temperature-relative humidity interaction for crush value showed a steep elliptical contour, while the CO2 concentration-relative humidity interaction for apparent density presented a flat parabolic surface. These results highlighted the innovation of applying RSM to decipher complex multi-factor couplings, which previous studies did not fully address. [Conclusion] This study successfully develops and validates RSM-based regression models for optimizing the CO2 reinforcement of RCA, with high reliability and precision confirmed by statistical indicators and experimental validation. The optimal conditions effectively improve RCA properties and provide a sustainable solution for waste concrete recycling and carbon emission reduction. The developed model offers a reliable reference for industrial applications, facilitating the adoption of CO2 -modified RCA in concrete production. Future research can apply this approach to other aggregate types or larger-scale scenarios, further advancing a circular economy in the construction industry.

Key words

recycled coarse aggregate / optimization of CO2 modification conditions / response surface method / interactions / crush value / water absorption / apparent density

Cite this article

Download Citations
CAO Fu-bo , SU Yu-tong , WANG Chen-xia , et al . Optimal Coupling Conditions for CO2-Reinforced Recycled Coarse Aggregate Based on Response Surface Method[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute. 2025, 42(12): 151-159 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20241109

References

[1]
KALIYAVARADHAN S K, LING T C. Potential of CO2 Sequestration through Construction and Demolition (C&D) Waste—An Overview[J]. Journal of CO2 Utilization, 2017, 20: 234-242.
[2]
肖建庄, 马旭伟, 刘琼, 等. 全再生混凝土概念的衍化与研究进展[J]. 建筑科学与工程学报, 2021, 38(2): 1-15.
(XIAO Jian-zhuang, MA Xu-wei, LIU Qiong, et al. Evolvement and Research Progress of Concept for Full Recycled Concrete[J]. Journal of Architecture and Civil Engineering, 2021, 38(2): 1-15. (in Chinese))
[3]
刘锟, 陈宣东, 黄达. 再生混凝土的研究现状及未来研究趋势分析[J]. 混凝土, 2020(10):47-50.
(LIU Kun, CHEN Xuan-dong, HUANG Da. Analysis on the Research Current Situation and Ruture Trends of Recycled Concrete and Analysis of Future Research Trends[J]. Concrete, 2020(10): 47-50. (in Chinese))
[4]
张金喜, 张建华, 邬长森. 再生混凝土性能和孔结构的研究[J]. 建筑材料学报, 2006, 9(2): 142-147.
(ZHANG Jin-xi, ZHANG Jian-hua, WU Chang-sen. Study on Properties and Pore Structure of Recycled Concrete[J]. Journal of Building Materials, 2006, 9(2): 142-147. (in Chinese))
[5]
肖建庄, 李佳彬, 孙振平, 等. 再生混凝土的抗压强度研究[J]. 同济大学学报(自然科学版), 2004, 32(12): 1558-1561.
(XIAO Jian-zhuang, LI Jia-bin, SUN Zhen-ping, et al. Study on Compressive Strength of Recycled Aggregate Concrete[J]. Journal of Tongji University, 2004, 32(12): 1558-1561. (in Chinese))
[6]
段珍华, 侯少丹, 潘智生, 等. 再生细骨料混凝土流变性及其对强度和耐久性的影响[J]. 建筑结构学报, 2020, 41(增刊2): 420-426.
(DUAN Zhen-hua, HOU Shao-dan, PAN Zhi-sheng, et al. Rheology of Recycled Fine Aggregate Concrete and Its Influence on Strength and Durability[J]. Journal of Building Structures, 2020, 41(Supp. 2): 420-426. (in Chinese))
[7]
赵增丰, 姚磊, 肖建庄, 等. 再生骨料CO2碳化强化技术研究进展[J]. 硅酸盐学报, 2022, 50(8): 2296-2304.
(ZHAO Zeng-feng, YAO Lei, XIAO Jian-zhuang, et al. Development on Accelerated Carbonation Technology to Enhance Recycled Aggregates[J]. Journal of the Chinese Ceramic Society, 2022, 50(8): 2296-2304. (in Chinese))
[8]
王佃超, 肖建庄, 夏冰, 等. 再生骨料碳化改性及其减碳贡献分析[J]. 同济大学学报(自然科学版), 2022, 50(11): 1610-1619.
(WANG Dian-chao, XIAO Jian-zhuang, XIA Bing, et al. Carbonation Modification of Recycled Aggregate and Carbon Dioxide Sequestration Analysis[J]. Journal of Tongji University (Natural Science), 2022, 50(11): 1610-1619. (in Chinese))
[9]
ZHAO Z, REMOND S, DAMIDOT D, et al. Improving the Properties of Recycled Concrete Aggregates by Accelerated Carbonation[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Construction Materials, 2018, 171(3): 126-132.
Large amounts of construction and demolition wastes, especially concrete wastes, are generated annually. Until now, only a small fraction of concrete wastes has been reused as recycled concrete aggregates (RCA) in the manufacture of mortar and concrete. In order to optimise the use of RCA for new concrete, it is important to improve the properties of RCA. RCA are mainly composed of an intimate mix of natural aggregates and adherent hardened cement paste, which has a much larger porosity than natural aggregates. The influence of accelerated carbonation on the properties of RCA was studied in this work. Original concrete was manufactured and crushed by a jaw crusher in the laboratory. The different fractions of laboratory-produced RCA were stored in an accelerated carbonation room. The mass loss, density, porosity and water absorption of the RCA were tested before and after carbonation. Industrial RCA were also studied for comparison with the laboratory-produced RCA. The results clearly showed that, after accelerated carbonation, the density of the RCA increased due to the transformation of portlandite into calcite. The water absorption and porosity of the RCA decreased after carbonation.
[10]
PAN G, ZHAN M, FU M, et al. Effect of CO2 Curing on Demolition Recycled Fine Aggregates Enhanced by Calcium Hydroxide Pre-soaking[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2017, 154: 810-818.
[11]
ZHAN M, PAN G, WANG Y, et al. Effect of Presoak-accelerated Carbonation Factors on Enhancing Recycled Aggregate Mortars[J]. Magazine of Concrete Research, 2017, 69(16): 838-849.
As the low content of calcium-bearing components in demolished recycled fine aggregates (RFA) significantly limits the carbon dioxide (CO2) curing efficiency, the effects of pre-soaking demolished RFA with calcium source solutions before the curing process are presented in this paper. Effects of varied types of calcium source solutions, including calcium hydroxide (CH), calcium chloride (CL) and calcium nitrate (CN) on the curing process are investigated. In addition, the influence of the other two parameters pertaining to curing conditions, namely, the carbon dioxide pressure and curing temperature, on the curing process are also studied. The experimental results show that, after the pre-soaking and curing process, the values of powder content, water absorption and crush value are all decreased for RFA. Furthermore, the compressive strength of mortars at 28 d are increased by as much as 56%. In addition, CN pre-soaking allows the RFA to achieve the lowest water absorption, and CL pre-soaking enables the mortars to obtain the highest compressive strength at 28 d; increasing gas pressure brings about a minor improvement in the properties of RFA and mortars, and curing temperature has complex effects on the carbonation reactions.
[12]
DROUET E, POYET S, LE BESCOP P, et al. Carbonation of Hardened Cement Pastes: Influence of Temperature[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 2019, 115: 445-459.
The impact of temperature on carbonation was investigated in laboratory conditions using a device developed for this purpose. Two hardened cement pastes (CEM I and CEM V/A) were tested between 20 degrees C and 80 degrees C at different levels of relative humidity (RH). The carbonation rate of the CEM I increased with temperature, whereas that of CEM V/A reached a maximum at around 50 degrees C.
[13]
FANG X, XUAN D, POON C S. Empirical Modelling of CO2 Uptake by Recycled Concrete Aggregates under Accelerated Carbonation Conditions[J]. Materials and Structures, 2017, 50(4): 200.
[14]
ZHAN B J, XUAN D X, POON C S, et al. Effect of Curing Parameters on CO2 Curing of Concrete Blocks Containing Recycled Aggregates[J]. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2016, 71: 122-130.
[15]
赵选民. 试验设计方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2006.
(ZHAO Xuan-min. Experimental Design Methods[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2006. (in Chinese))
[16]
魏凯伦, 赵卫全, 樊恒辉. 基于响应面法的硅溶胶注浆材料配比优化研究[J]. 硅酸盐通报, 2022, 41(6): 2015-2023.
Abstract
硅溶胶注浆材料具有可注性好、凝胶时间可控、环保无毒、耐久性高等优点,但常规的硅溶胶固砂体抗压强度偏低,其推广应用受到了一定限制。本文通过单因素实验分别研究了胶凝剂种类、胶凝剂浓度、硅溶胶与胶凝剂质量比、注浆材料pH值对硅溶胶固砂体抗压强度的影响,同时通过响应面法研究了胶凝剂浓度、硅溶胶与胶凝剂质量比、注浆材料pH值交互作用对抗压强度的影响。试验结果表明:单因素对抗压强度影响的显著程度依次为胶凝剂浓度、注浆材料pH值、硅溶胶与胶凝剂质量比;双因素交互作用对抗压强度影响的显著程度依次为胶凝剂浓度和注浆材料pH值、胶凝剂浓度和硅溶胶与胶凝剂质量比、硅溶胶与胶凝剂质量比和注浆材料pH值。采用响应面法获得的硅溶胶固砂体抗压强度最优配比为胶凝剂质量浓度为7%,硅溶胶与胶凝剂质量比为7 ∶1,注浆材料pH值为7。响应面法的预测值和实测值误差较小,表明响应面法可用于硅溶胶注浆材料的配比优化。
(WEI Kai-lun, ZHAO Wei-quan, FAN Heng-hui. Proportion Optimization of Silica Sol Grout Based on Response Surface Method[J]. Bulletin of the Chinese Ceramic Society, 2022, 41(6): 2015-2023. (in Chinese))
Silica sol grout has advantages of good groutability, controllable gelation time, non-toxicity and high durability, however the compressive strength of silica sol grouted sand is relatively low, which restricts its application. In this paper, a series of single-factor tests were carried out to examine the effects of various factors on the compressive strength of grouted sand. Those factors include the type and concentration of gel-agent, the mass ratio of silica sol to gel-agent and the pH value of grout. In addition, response surface method was used to studythe effect of the interaction of the factors including the concentration of gel-agent, the mass ratio of silica sol to gel-agent and the pH value of grout on the compressive strength of grouted sand. The experimental results demonstrate that the following factors are arranged in a descending order in terms of the influencing degree of a single factor, the concentration of gel-agent, the pH value of grout and the mass ratio of silica sol to gel-agent. Moreover, the following factors are arranged in a similar manner regarding interaction effects between two factors, interaction between gel-agent concentration and grout pH value, interaction between gel-agent concentration and the mass ratio of silica sol to gel-agent, and interaction between the mass ratio of silica sol to gel-agent and the pH value of grout. Based on response surface method, the optimized compressive strength of silica sol grouted sand can be achieved when the mass concentration of gel-agent, the mass ratio of silica sol to gel-agent and the pH value of grout are selected as 7%, 7 ∶1 and 7, respectively. The difference between predicted values of response surface method and experimental measurement is minor, suggesting that response surface method can be used to optimize the proportion of silica sol grout.
[17]
樊成, 王子源, 祁鹏飞, 等. 基于响应面法的某粉质黏土深基坑土钉参数分析与优化[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2025, 42 (4): 142-148.
Abstract
为揭示土钉设计中空间形态参数等因素对粉质黏土深基坑三维稳定性的影响规律,以河北某粉质黏土地区深基坑为工程背景,基于响应面法设计Plackett-Burman与Box-Behnken试验,采用MIDAS-GTS与Design-Expert软件建立试验模型。通过数值模拟与监测数据分析了各参数对粉质黏土深基坑土钉支护安全性的影响规律及优化方案的适用性。结果表明:各参数对粉质黏土地区基坑支护稳定性的影响程度从大到小依次为土钉长度、放坡坡角、土钉间距、土钉倾角、土钉直径。在支护参数的组合作用中,土钉长度与土钉间距对安全系数的影响最大。利用响应面法建立的预测模型能够提供最佳的优化方案,优化方案使土体滑移面后移,基坑的最大水平位移由9.33 mm减至5.42 mm,最大竖直沉降由16.9 mm减至11.8 mm,为该类型基坑土钉支护设计提供了参考。
(FAN Cheng, WANG Zi-yuan, QI Peng-fei, et al. Analysis and Optimization of Soil Nail Parameters in a Deep Foundation Pit of Silty Clay Based on Response Surface Methodology[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute, 2025, 42 (4): 142-148. (in Chinese))
[18]
吴浩, 赵国彦, 陈英, 等. 基于RSM-DF的矿山充填材料配比优化[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报, 2019, 27(2): 453-461.
(WU Hao, ZHAO Guo-yan, CHEN Ying, et al. Optimization of Mix Proportioning of Mine Filling Materials Using RSM-DF Experiments Design Method[J]. Journal of Basic Science and Engineering, 2019, 27(2): 453-461. (in Chinese))
[19]
黄炜, 郭余婷, 葛培, 等. 基于响应面法的聚丙烯纤维再生砖骨料混凝土配合比优化[J]. 中南大学学报(自然科学版), 2022, 53(7): 2709-2718.
(HUANG Wei, GUO Yu-ting, GE Pei, et al. Mixture Ratio Optimization of Polypropylene Fiber Recycled Brick Aggregate Concrete Based on Response Surface Methodology[J]. Journal of Central South University (Science and Technology), 2022, 53(7): 2709-2718. (in Chinese))
PDF(7949 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/