Structural Feedback Analysis Based on Monitoring Data from Units with Different Spiral Case Embedding Methods at Three Gorges Hydropower Station

CHEN Qin, SU Hai-dong, DUAN Guo-xue, CUI Jian-hua, ZHOU Shi-hua

Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2025, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (8) : 135-143.

PDF(7604 KB)
PDF(7604 KB)
Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2025, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (8) : 135-143. DOI: 10.11988/ckyyb.20240853
Hydraulic Structure And Material

Structural Feedback Analysis Based on Monitoring Data from Units with Different Spiral Case Embedding Methods at Three Gorges Hydropower Station

Author information +
History +

Abstract

[Objective] The Three Gorges Hydropower Station is the only mega hydropower station in the world that employs three embedding methods of spiral cases. The operational conditions and differences among the units with these different embedding methods have attracted widespread attention. As the supporting system of hydroelectric generators, both the steel spiral cases and surrounding reinforced concrete structures have significant differences in construction processes and structural bearing characteristics due to different embedding methods. This study aims to comprehensively evaluate structural safety conditions, providing a basis for the safe operation of the power station and offering references for structural design and embedding method selection at other power stations. [Methods] Based on the monitoring data from the real-machine performance tests conducted during the experimental impoundment period of the Three Gorges Project, units with three types of spiral case embedding methods in the right-bank power plant were selected as the research subjects. The three-dimensional finite element method was used to conduct feedback comparative analysis of relevant monitoring parameters to summarize the structural bearing patterns and differences among different embedding methods of spiral cases. [Results] The finite element calculation results were consistent with the patterns of the monitored data, with close numerical values, validating the credibility of the monitoring results and the rationality of the design research and calculation methods. Under water pressure, the tensile stresses generated in both concrete and steel spiral cases were significantly greater in the circumferential direction than in the flow direction. The concrete bearing ratio of the direct embedding method was significantly higher than that of the other two schemes, while the stresses in concrete and steel spiral cases were generally at the same level in the pressure-maintaining and cushion methods. The concrete stress distribution in the direct embedding and pressure-maintaining methods was more uniform than in the cushion method. The stresses in the steel flow passage components, reinforcement bars, and the relative uplift displacement of lower frame foundation all remained within the design limits. The non-uniform uplift displacement of the lower frame foundation in the direct embedding method was notably greater than in other methods. Under thermal loading, concrete and steel spiral cases exhibited identical stress variation patterns. Tensile stresses developed during cooling and compressive stresses developed during heating. The stress in the flow direction was significantly greater than in the circumferential direction, and the magnitude of the stress increments was minimally affected by the spiral case embedding method. [Conclusions] Comprehensive analysis indicates that during the operation period, the structural concrete and steel components under all three embedding methods remain in the elastic stage of the materials, and the units are operating under the normal conditions anticipated in the design.

Key words

Three Gorges Hydropower Station / spiral case embedding / unit monitoring / feedback analysis / structural bearing

Cite this article

Download Citations
CHEN Qin , SU Hai-dong , DUAN Guo-xue , et al . Structural Feedback Analysis Based on Monitoring Data from Units with Different Spiral Case Embedding Methods at Three Gorges Hydropower Station[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute. 2025, 42(8): 135-143 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20240853

References

[1]
林绍忠, 苏海东. 水电站蜗壳保压浇混凝土结构的三维仿真分析[J]. 水利学报, 2002, 33(1): 66-70.
(LIN Shao-zhong, SU Hai-dong. 3-D FEM Analysis for Surrounding Concrete of Steel Spiral Case Keeping Internal Pressure during Construction[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2002, 33(1): 66-70.(in Chinese))
[2]
袁达夫, 谢红兵. 大型混流式水轮机蜗壳的埋设方式[J]. 人民长江, 2009, 40(16): 37-39.
(YUAN Da-fu, XIE Hong-bing. Embedding Method of Volute of Large Francis Turbine[J]. Yangtze River, 2009, 40(16): 37-39.(in Chinese))
[3]
钮新强, 谢红兵, 刘志明. 三峡右岸电站蜗壳直埋方案研究[J]. 人民长江, 2008, 39(1): 1-2, 12, 106.
(NIU Xin-qiang, XIE Hong-bing, LIU Zhi-ming. Research for Direct Embedding Scheme of Spiral Case of TGP Power Station on Right Bank[J]. Yangtze River, 2008, 39(1): 1-2, 12, 106.(in Chinese))
[4]
陈琴, 苏海东, 崔建华, 等. 大型机组蜗壳不同埋设方式的结构开裂分析[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2009, 26(4): 40-43.
Abstract
三峡电站水轮机组蜗壳采用保压、垫层、直埋3种埋设方式,其中左岸保压方案机组已安全稳定运行,直埋方案为国内首次应用于大型机组。为比较不同埋设方式下的结构开裂及位移等情况,并为垫层方案尤其是直埋方案机组提供借鉴,对蜗壳3种不同埋设方式下的蜗壳流道及外围钢筋混凝土结构进行开裂分析,研究裂缝分布、钢衬钢筋应力、结构位移等问题。计算结果表明:混凝土开裂范围和结构上抬位移均以直埋方案最大,保压方案最小;垫层方案和保压方案差别较小,可以成功运用于三峡机组,而直埋方案只要采取有效的结构加强措施,也能达到安全稳定运行的要求。
(CHEN Qin, SU Hai-dong, CUI Jian-hua, et al. Crack Analysis on Spiral Case Structure of Largescale Turbine Units with Different Embedded Manners[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2009, 26(4): 40-43.(in Chinese))
There are three manners of spiral cases embedment in concrete in TGP, i.e., spirals are embedded with keeping constant internal pressure, embedded with cushion layers and embedded directly. The turbine units on the left bank, in which the spiral case was embedded with constant internal pressure, have operated safely for some years.? Applying the spiral case embedded directly in large scale turbine was the first time in domestic project. In order to compare and analyze the structure cracks and displacements under different embedded manners, and furthermore, to provide a reference for cushion layers method and embedded directly method, crack analysis on the spiral case flow passage and outer reinforced concrete structure was carried out. The distribution of cracks, stresses of steel liner and rising displacements of the structure were studied. The computed results showed that the concrete cracks range and rising displacements of the structure are the largest in direct embedment? manner, that those are the least in embedment manner with keeping constant internal pressure, and that there is a little difference result between cushion layers manner and keeping constant internal pressure manner, therefore, two manners can be adopted successfully in TGP turbine units. The direct embedment manner can also make the units operation safety when the effectively strengthening structure measure is adopted.
[5]
张运良, 马震岳, 程国瑞, 等. 水轮机蜗壳不同埋设方式的流道结构刚强度分析[J]. 水利学报, 2006, 37(10):1206-1211.
(ZHANG Yun-liang, MA Zhen-yue, CHENG Guo-rui, et al. Strength and Stiffness Analysis of Spiral Casing with Different Embedded Manners[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2006, 37(10):1206-1211.(in Chinese))
[6]
彭绍才, 段国学, 黎晶晶. 三峡右岸电站机组蜗壳应力监测成果分析[J]. 人民长江, 2009, 40(23): 78-80.
(PENG Shao-cai, DUAN Guo-xue, LI Jing-jing. Analysis of Stress Monitoring Results of Spiral Case of Unit in Three Gorges Right Bank Power Station[J]. Yangtze River, 2009, 40(23): 78-80.(in Chinese))
[7]
彭绍才, 段国学, 武方洁. 三峡水轮机蜗壳充水加压过程应力分析[J]. 人民长江, 2011, 42(10): 87-90.
(PENG Shao-cai, DUAN Guo-xue, WU Fang-jie. Analysis of Stress during Water Filling and Pressure Increasing Process of Turbine Spiral Casing of Three Gorges Power Plant[J]. Yangtze River, 2011, 42(10): 87-90.(in Chinese))
[8]
杨爱明, 段国学, 马能武. 三峡工程建设与运行期建筑物安全监测资料分析[J]. 中国工程科学, 2011, 13(7):117-122.
(YANG Ai-ming, DUAN Guo-xue, MA Neng-wu. The Analysis on Structure Safety Monitoring Data of Three Gorges Project in Construction and Operation[J]. Engineering Sciences, 2011, 13(7):117-122.(in Chinese))
[9]
崔建华, 苏海东, 陈琴. 三峡左岸电站蜗壳保压浇筑外围混凝土仿真计算[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2009, 26(7): 43-47.
Abstract
三峡工程左岸电站采用保压方式浇筑蜗壳外围混凝土。为研究钢蜗壳与外围二期混凝土交界面的传力以及可能存在的间隙,采用三维非线性有限元法,对左岸10#机组进行模拟施工过程的温度场与温度应力仿真计算,给出了在不同运行情况及不同季节时二者之间传力及间隙的变化。计算值与现场观测值有很好的一致性。
(CUI Jian-hua, SU Hai-dong, CHEN Qin. 3-D FEM Emulation Computation on Surrounding Concrete of Steel Spiral Case Keeping Internal Pressure during Construction for TGP[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2009, 26(7): 43-47.(in Chinese))
The surrounding concrete of steel spiral case in the power station of Three Gorges Project(TGP) is constructed by means of keeping aspecific level of internal pressure during construction. For analyzing the contact behavior of the interface between the steel spiral case and its surrounding concrete,the numerical simulations of the construction process according to the actual construction procedure are carried out with 3-D FEM.The variation of the gap and the interaction force between the steel spiral case and its surrounding concrete in different operation stages and different seasons are put forward. By comparing the? computed results with the prototype safety monitored data during and after the construction of surrounding concrete, it shows that they are in good agreement. The method and the program are proved to be feasible.
[10]
陈琴, 苏海东, 崔建华, 等. 基于三峡水电站15号机组监测资料的结构反馈分析[J]. 武汉大学学报(工学版), 2018, 51(9): 766-771, 797.
(CHEN Qin, SU Hai-dong, CUI Jian-hua, et al. Structural Feedback Analysis Based on Monitoring Data of No.15 Unit of Three Gorges Hydropower Station[J]. Engineering Journal of Wuhan University, 2018, 51(9): 766-771, 797.(in Chinese))
[11]
周述达, 段国学, 王煌. 三峡电站巨型蜗壳埋设方式的设计与实践[C]//三峡工程正常蓄水位175米试验性蓄水运行十年论文集. 武汉: 长江出版社,2019:322-332.
(ZHOU Shu-da, DUAN Guo-xue, WANG Huang. Design and Practice of Lagre-scale Spiral Case Embedding Manners of Three Gorges Hydropower Project[C]//Papers on Trial Impoundment Operation of Three Gorge Project at 175 m Water Level in Past Ten Years. Wuhan: Changing Press, 2019:322-332.(in Chinese))
PDF(7604 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/