PDF(7069 KB)
长江宜昌江段四大家鱼产卵场亲鱼集群生境适宜性评价
戴凌全, 刘璇, 李秋平, 曹光荣, 刘瀚, 郜星晨, 周文浩, 姜伟
长江科学院院报 ›› 2026, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (5) : 58-66.
PDF(7069 KB)
PDF(7069 KB)
长江宜昌江段四大家鱼产卵场亲鱼集群生境适宜性评价
Assessment of Habitat Suitability for Spawning Schooling of Four Major Chinese Carps in Yichang River Section of Yangtze River
适宜的水动力条件是四大家鱼亲鱼集群产卵的关键生态基础。为明确宜昌江段四大家鱼亲鱼集群的适宜生态流量,提出了亲鱼集群的水动力适宜性曲线,并构建了产卵场三维水动力模型和物理栖息地模型(PHABSIM)。通过模拟三峡水库不同出库流量下四大家鱼集群栖息地加权可利用体积(WUV),定量评估了四大家鱼集群生境的空间响应特征。结果表明:宜昌江段四大家鱼亲鱼集群的WUV随着流量增加呈先增大再缓慢减小的趋势,当出库流量为14 000 m3/s时WUV达到最大,占研究河段总体积(PUV)的71.7%;促进宜昌江段四大家鱼集群的三峡水库生态调度出库流量应维持为10 000~20 000 m3/s,最优出库流量为12 000~16 000 m3/s。研究成果可为三峡水库精准实施针对四大家鱼集群等关键生活史的生态水利过程调控、提升水库生态效益提供科学依据。
[Objective] Promoting the natural spawning of fish through reservoir operation is an important and effective measure for enhancing the ecological benefits of reservoirs. From 2011 to 2025, the Three Gorges Reservoir (TGR) conducted 24 ecological operation tests over 15 consecutive years to promote the spawning of the four major Chinese carps (FMCC) and facilitate the recovery of fish resources. However, early-stage fish resource monitoring data indicate that the responses of FMCC to each ecological operation test vary, with spawning effects being pronounced in some cases but suboptimal in others. Therefore, attention should be focused on the schooling behavior of the parent fish of FMCC in the Yichang river section, and appropriate hydrodynamic conditions constitute a key ecological basis for their spawning. [Methods] To determine the appropriate ecological flow for FMCC parent fish schooling in the Yichang river section, this study began with the ecohydraulics requirements of the parent fish schooling, proposed a hydrodynamic suitability curve based on previous monitoring results and existing literature, established a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model and a Physical Habitat Simulation Model (PHABSIM) of the spawning site, analyzed the hydraulic habitat suitability of FMCC under different flow conditions, and identified the ecological flow range suitable for parent fish schooling. [Results] By simulating the weighted usable volume (WUV) of FMCC spawning schooling habitats under different outflows from the TGR, the spatial response characteristics of the schooling habitat were quantitatively evaluated. Overall, WUV first increased and then decreased as the flow of the spawning site increased. At a flow of 14 000 m3/s, WUV reached its maximum, accounting for 71.7% of the percent usable volume (PUV) of the study area. Under this flow, conditions were favorable for forming a larger, more concentrated, and well-connected schooling-suitable habitat. Under high flow conditions exceeding 22 000 m3/s, the increased flow velocity and intensified vertical velocity gradient hindered the formation of stable FMCC spawning schooling, significantly reducing the suitable habitat volume. Therefore, to promote parent fish schooling, flow should not be too high. The optimal flow range should be 10 000-20 000 m3/s, accounting for more than 64.3% of PUV, which was conducive to forming a three-dimensional habitat suitable for FMCC schooling and maintaining high ecological stability. The suitable flow velocity and depth ranges for parent fish spawning schooling in the Yichang river section were 0.9-1.4 m/s and 3.0-5.0 m, respectively. FMCC habitat suitability in the study area exhibited distinct vertical and horizontal spatial distribution patterns. At a flow of 14 000 m3/s, the average velocity in the upper layer was 1.10 m/s, while in the lower layer it was 0.75 m/s. For the upper-middle layer, flow velocity, depth, and comprehensive suitability index were 0.90, 0.91, and 0.84 respectively, whereas for the bottom layer, they were 0.89, 0.65 and 0.57. The upper-middle layer outperformed the bottom layer, particularly in terms of depth and comprehensive suitability index, indicating that the upper-middle layer provided more stable and suitable habitat conditions for FMCC. [Conclusion] Using an unstructured irregular triangular mesh, a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of the FMCC spawning site in the Yichang river section is established. The model accuracy meets the requirements, enabling accurate simulation of the hydrodynamic characteristics of the spawning site under different flow conditions. Before spawning, parent fish tend to occupy the upper-middle layer, and their behavior is more sensitive to flow conditions. The flows of 10 000-20 000 m3/s favor parent fish schooling, with the most suitable range being 12 000-16 000 m3/s. The findings provide a scientific basis for the TGR to precisely regulate ecological water management during key life history stages, such as parent fish schooling, thereby enhancing the ecological benefits of the reservoir.
四大家鱼 / 产卵集群 / 水文水动力 / 适宜性评价 / 三峡水库 / 生态调度
four major Chinese carps / spawning schooling / hydrological and hydrodynamic conditions / suitability assessment / Three Gorges Reservoir / ecological operation
| [1] |
李建, 夏自强, 王远坤, 等. 长江中游四大家鱼产卵场河段形态与水流特性研究[J]. 四川大学学报(工程科学版), 2010, 42(4): 63-70.
(
|
| [2] |
柏海霞, 彭期冬, 李翀, 等. 长江四大家鱼产卵场地形及其自然繁殖水动力条件研究综述[J]. 中国水利水电科学研究院学报, 2014, 12(3): 249-257.
(
|
| [3] |
彭期冬, 廖文根, 李翀, 等. 三峡工程蓄水以来对长江中游四大家鱼自然繁殖影响研究[J]. 四川大学学报(工程科学版), 2012, 44 (增刊2): 228-232.
(
|
| [4] |
段辛斌, 陈大庆, 李志华, 等. 三峡水库蓄水后长江中游产漂流性卵鱼类产卵场现状[J]. 中国水产科学, 2008, 15(4): 523-532.
(
|
| [5] |
|
| [6] |
程根伟, 陈桂蓉. 试验三峡水库生态调度,促进长江水沙科学管理[J]. 水利学报, 2007, 38(增刊1):526-530.
(
|
| [7] |
董哲仁, 孙东亚, 赵进勇. 水库多目标生态调度[J]. 水利水电技术, 2007, 38(1):28-32.
(
|
| [8] |
熊明, 郭卫. 面向产漂流性卵鱼类繁殖的水电站生态水文过程调控[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2023, 40(10): 1-5.
基于水利工程影响下的产漂流性卵鱼类繁殖需求分析,开发了一种面向产漂流性卵鱼类繁殖的水电站生态水文过程调控方法,通过同步滚动调整启动时机和变动出库流量增幅来人工制造生态脉冲;在确定调控原则和目标的基础上,提出了水电站生态水文调控模型,并进行模型求解;在金沙江中游河段目标鱼类繁殖所需生态脉冲过程、中长期来水预测已知的前提下,将模型应用到梨园水电站生态水文调控实践,结果显示与模型类似工况的求解结果相近。实例验证了所提方法的可行性,可为其他已建水电站开展生态水文调控提供参考。
(
|
| [9] |
龚文婷, 李帅, 姜伟, 等. 面向鱼类产卵繁殖的人造洪峰生态调度实践: 以金沙江下游-三峡梯级水库为例[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2024(10): 65-72.
2011-2023年，金沙江下游-三峡梯级水库共开展了20次面向鱼类产卵繁殖的人造洪峰生态调度试验，在取得良好试验成效的同时积累了大量的经验。为系统梳理多年来的生态调度试验成效及经验，详细介绍了金沙江下游-三峡梯级水库人造洪峰生态调度试验的原理、要点、监测评价方法，回顾了历年调度试验开展情况，总结了调度经验并对未来优化方向进行了展望。结果表明，金下-三峡梯级水库人造洪峰生态调度试验有效促进了长江干流产漂流性卵鱼类产卵繁殖，其中三峡水库促进坝下代表性产漂流性卵鱼类——四大家鱼自然产卵繁殖效果最为显著。截至2023年，长江中游四大家鱼累计总产卵规模达382.5亿粒。在多年生态调度和十年禁渔计划等工作的共同推动下，四大家鱼资源量基本接近20世纪80年代水平。然而，受气候变化、鱼类产卵及发育特性变化、产卵场变化等因素的影响，人造洪峰生态调度试验需要在调度过程优化、调度效果评价、调度效果提升等方面开展针对性地优化调整。相关结果可为变化环境下相似流域开展面向鱼类产卵繁殖的人造洪峰生态调度试验提供参考。
(
From 2011 to 2023， a total of 20 ecological operation experiments of artificial flood peak were conducted in the Lower Jinsha River-Three Gorges cascade reservoirs， focusing on the fish spawning， and a lot of experience was accumulated while achieving good experiments results. In order to systematically figure out the effectiveness and experience of the ecological operation experiments of artificial flood peak over the years， this paper takes the Lower Jinsha River-Three Gorges cascade reservoirs as an example. First， the principles， key points， monitoring and evaluation methods of the ecological operation experiments of artificial flood peak were introduced. Second， the development of operation experiments over the years was reviewed. Finally， the operation experience was summarized and the future optimal direction was proposed. The results showed that the ecological operation experiments of artificial flood peak in the Lower Jinsha River-Three Gorges cascade reservoirs effectively promoted the spawning of fishes spawning drifting eggs in the Yangtze River. The effect of promoting the natural spawning of the representative fishes spawning drifting eggs——the four major Chinese carps under the dam is the most significant in the Three Gorges Reservoir. By 2023， the total spawning scale of the four major Chinese carps in the middle reaches of the Yangtze River reached 38.25 billion. Under the joint promotion of multi-year ecological operation practice and 10-year fishing ban plan， the fish resources of the four major Chinese carps is close to the level of the 1980s. However， under the influence of climate change， fish spawning and developmental characteristics change， spawning ground change and other factors， the ecological operation experiments of artificial flood peak need to carry out targeted optimization and adjustment in the aspects of operation process optimization， operation effect evaluation， and operation effect improvement. The results can provide a reference for the ecological operation of artificial flood peak for fish spawning in similar basins under changing environment. |
| [10] |
刘瀚, 林俊强, 秦鑫, 等. 基于生物水文响应模型的刺激四大家鱼繁殖生态调度目标量化方法研究: 以三峡水库为例[J]. 湖泊科学, 2023, 35(5): 1741-1751.
(
|
| [11] |
李莎, 刘雪清, 姜伟, 等. 环境DNA技术在宜昌江段四大家鱼自然繁殖中的应用[J]. 应用生态学报, 2021, 32(6): 2241-2248.
本研究通过环境DNA(eDNA)技术的样品采集及DNA提取方法,采用微滴式数字PCR(ddPCR)技术检测了长江干流宜昌江段不同水层、不同断面四大家鱼的eDNA浓度,分析了eDNA浓度变化与卵苗密度的关系,探讨了利用eDNA技术监测四大家鱼自然繁殖情况的可行性。结果表明: 与传统调查结果相比,四大家鱼的eDNA浓度与卵苗密度呈极显著相关,浓度最大值与卵苗峰值的出现时间较为一致,利用eDNA技术可以预判家鱼集群产卵行为的发生。连续两年的断面eDNA浓度检测认为,渔洋溪上游4.5 km和下游1 km为家鱼产卵场。该范围位于传统方法预估的胭脂坝下至红花套的产卵场范围内。这说明eDNA技术作为一种新兴的生态调查方法,可更为准确地判定有一定种群规模的鱼种的分布情况,因此具有很好的应用前景。
(
We explored the sample collection and DNA extraction method of environmental DNA (eDNA) technique. Droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) was used to detect the eDNA concentration of the four major Chinese carps in different water layers and different cross-sections of Yichang section of Yangtze River trunk stream. We analyzed the relationship between eDNA concentration and density of egg and fry, and explored the feasibility of using eDNA technique to monitor the natural reproduction of the four major Chinese carps. Compared with the results from traditional survey methods, the eDNA concentration of the four major Chinese carps was extremely significantly correlated with egg and fry density. The maximum concentration was consistent with the peak occurrence time of egg and fry, suggesting that eDNA technique could predict the fishcrowd behavior for spawning. The investigation of cross-section eDNA concentration during two consecutive years suggested that the range of fish spawning ground was 4.5 km upstream to 1 km downstream of Yuyangxi. The predicted spawning ground was located within the range estimated by traditional methods from the lower part of Carmine Dam to Honghua Tuo. Our results indicate that eDNA technique, as a new ecological investigation method, could more accurately determine the distribution of fish with a certain population size, and thus with a good application prospect.
|
| [12] |
周应祺, 王军, 钱卫国, 等. 鱼类集群行为的研究进展[J]. 上海海洋大学学报, 2013, 22(5): 734-743.
(
|
| [13] |
|
| [14] |
This paper describes the main characteristics of sardine schools detected in the Spanish-Atlantic surveys carried out from 1992 to 1997 (except 1994). A series of parameters were obtained for each school (morphological, positional and energetic) as well as environmental factors (temperature and salinity). The relationships between the school parameters were analyzed by a PCA and then the school parameters per se were described using both univariate and multivariate analyses (Box-plots, ANOVAs, MANOVA, and discriminant analysis). The results show that significant differences exist between years and geographic areas in that the Rías Baixas schools were smaller in size and of higher density than those from the Cantabric area. These differences could be related to the facts that the Rías Baixas is a nursery zone and sardine length and age are smaller than in the Cantabric Sea. It would seem that the differences in school morphology and energetic characteristics related to length and age of individuals allow us to distinguish between the sardine echo traces in this area. There is a high annual variability in the number of schools and this is not a function of either survey design or strategy and it is not related to the abundance estimates of sardine. These results are important for both future species identification and the improvement of survey design and strategy.
|
| [15] |
|
| [16] |
石小涛, 王博, 王雪, 等. 胭脂鱼早期发育过程中集群行为的形成[J]. 水产学报, 2013, 37(5): 705-710.
(
|
| [17] |
付世建, 聂利娟, 吴慧, 等. 群体大小对青幼鱼群体特征的影响[J]. 生态学报, 2016, 36(19): 6062-6070.
(
|
| [18] |
朱天然, 孙林, 李嘉, 等. 齐口裂腹鱼集群行为对流态的响应[J]. 农业工程学报, 2022, 38(11):144-150.
(
|
| [19] |
张兴磊, 樊寒冰, 薛敬阳, 等. 圆口铜鱼水力生境适宜度评价及集群区域预测[J]. 水电能源科学, 2022, 40(1):64-67.
(
|
| [20] |
赵涵婧, 韩建蓉, 金渝钦, 等. 群体大小对鳙幼鱼的集群行为影响[J]. 中国农学通报, 2022, 38(23): 143-149.
集群是自然界的一种普遍现象,大约有一半的鱼类一生中有部分或全部生活在鱼群中,为研究群体大小对鳙(Hypophthalmichthys nobilis)幼鱼集群行为的影响,选取了鳙幼鱼,利用Lolitrack软件比较不同尾数实验鱼群体的自发游泳速度以及空间分布的差异。研究发现：鳙幼鱼的自发游泳速度多分布在0~6 cm/s,1、2、4、8不同尾数实验鱼群体的平均速度无显著差异。各实验组的同步性都较高,且随着群体规模的上升有显著下降趋势,各组间均有显著性差异(P<0.05)。焦点鱼与群体中其它实验鱼的最近邻距离(NND)和平均邻距离大多分布在2~8 cm和4~14 cm,2尾鱼的NND显著大于4尾和8尾(P<0.05)。群体大小为2尾和4尾实验组的排列极性为83%、88%,显著高于8尾实验组68%(P<0.05)。研究结果表明,鳙幼鱼具有明显的集群性特征,群体的大小对鳙幼鱼自发游泳速度的影响较小,但对同步性、NND以及排列极性（即空间分布）有显著影响。本次研究探讨了群体大小对鳙鱼集群参数的影响,对经济鱼类的生态养殖和渔业管理具有十分重要的实践意义。
(
Collective behavior is a common phenomenon in nature, about half of all fish species shoal for part or all their lives. In order to investigate the effect of population size on the collective behavior of juvenile bighead carp (Hypophthalmichthys nobilis), the Lolitrack software was used to compare the differences in spontaneous swimming speed and spatial distribution among experimental fish populations with different numbers of individuals in this study. The results showed that the spontaneous swimming speed of juvenile bighead carp was mostly in the range of 0-6 cm/s, and there was no significant difference in the average swimming speed among populations with of 1, 2, 4 and 8 individuals, indicating that the population size had no significant effect on the spontaneous swimming speed of juvenile bighead carp. The synchrony of all experimental groups were high and significantly decreased with the increase of population size (P<0.05). The nearest neighbor distance (NND) and mean neighbor distance between the focus fish and other experimental fish in the population were mostly distributed at 2-8 cm and 4-14 cm, respectively. The NND of the population with 2 individuals was significantly higher than the population with 4 and 8 individuals (P<0.05). The polarity of populations with 2 (83%) and 4 (88%) individuals were significantly higher than that with 8 individuals (68%, P<0.05). In conclusion, these findings indicate that juvenile bighead carp has obvious collective behaviors. On the one hand, the population size has little effect on the spontaneous swimming speed of juvenile bighead carp, and on the other hand, the population size has significant effect on its spatial distribution. In this study, the effects of population size on the cluster parameters of bighead carp are investigated, and the study is of practical significance for ecological breeding and fishery management of economic fish. |
| [21] |
马卫忠, 安瑞冬, 李敏讷, 等. 洄游鱼类坝下集群的水动力学特征与行为预测[J]. 北京师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2021, 57(3):433-440.
(
|
| [22] |
张文鸽, 黄强, 蒋晓辉. 基于物理栖息地模拟的河道内生态流量研究[J]. 水科学进展, 2008, 19(2): 192-197.
(
|
| [23] |
|
| [24] |
傅菁菁, 黄滨, 芮建良, 等. 生境模拟法在黑水河鱼类栖息地保护中的应用[J]. 水生态学杂志, 2016, 37(3): 70-75.
(
|
| [25] |
戴凌全, 周文浩, 郜星晨, 等. 长江中游宜昌江段四大家鱼产卵量对水文要素的响应及生态调度策略[J]. 长江流域资源与环境, 2026, 35(3):606-616.
(
|
| [26] |
刘明典, 高雷, 田辉伍, 等. 长江中游宜昌江段鱼类早期资源现状[J]. 中国水产科学, 2018, 25(1):147-158.
(
|
| [27] |
李芳, 安瑞冬, 马卫忠, 等. 鱼类坝下集群效应对水力学条件的响应规律研究[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2018(10):87-91,117.
拦河筑坝阻隔了鱼类洄游通道，鱼类具有天然的溯流习性，会感应到主流上溯，为进行产卵、索饵和洄游在过鱼季节聚集在坝下，产生鱼类坝下集群效应。鱼类的集群行为是鱼类行为学研究的重要内容。影响鱼类集群的三个重要水力学条件有流速、水深、紊动能，为研究鱼类坝下集群效应对水力学条件的响应规律，亟需建立集群分布规律与上述三个水力学因子的相关性。本文采用三维湍流模型对观测时所处运行工况的坝下流域进行了数值模拟，并用试验验证了数值模拟的合理性，使用观测仪器探测坝下四大家鱼分布规律，分析集群行为特点及其相关性。研究表明：当流速处于0.7~0.24m/s之间时，鱼体数量与流速呈正线性相关，且四大家鱼集群最佳流速范围为0.060~0.12m/s；当水深值处于2.4m~3.9m之间时，鱼群数量与水深呈正线性相关关系，鱼类集群适宜水深下限值为2.8m；当紊动能值处于0~0.0012kg·m2/s2之间时，鱼体数量与紊动能有明显的正线性相关关系，当紊动能值处于0.0015~0.0040kg·m2/s2之间时，二者成负线性相关，且鱼类集群的平均紊动能适宜范围是0.00050~0.0012 kg·m2/s2。
(
Barrage and damming obstruct the migration of fish． Fish have a natural upstream habit and will be induced to the mainstream andmigrate． In order to spawn，bait and migrate，fish cluster under the dam，thus generating the fish schooling effect． Fish schooling behavior isan important part of fish behavior research． Velocity，depth and turbulent energy are three important factors affecting fish schooling． In orderto study the response pattern of fish schooling effect on the hydraulic characteristics under the dam，it is urgent for us to establish thecorrelation between the distribution rule of fish schooling and the above -mentioned three hydraulic factors． In this paper，the three -dimensional turbulence model is used to simulate the watershed under the dam in operating conditions during observation． The accuracy of thenumerical simulation is validated by experiments． The distribution of the four major Chinese carps under the dam is observed by usingobservation instruments，and the relevance of schooling behavior and hydraulic characteristics are analysed． The results show that when theflow velocity is between 0．70～ 0．24 m/s，the number of fish body is positively correlated with velocity，and the optimum flow velocity rangeof the four fish groups is 0．060 ～ 0．12 m/s． When water depth is between 2．4 ～ 3．9 m，there is a positive linear relationship between thenumber of fish and water depth，and the lower limit of favorable depth of fish schooling is 2．8 m． When the turbulence energy is between 0～0．001 2 kg·m2 /s2，there is a significant positive linear correlation between the number of fish and the turbulent energy，while performing anegative correlation when the turbulent energy ranges from 0．001 5 to 0．004 0 kg·m2 /s2．And the optimum average turbulence energy of fishschooling is 0．000 50～ 0．001 2 kg · m2 /s2．
|
| [28] |
俞立雄, 段辛斌, 陈大庆, 等. 5种鱼类标志对草鱼临界游泳速度的影响[J]. 中国水产科学, 2017, 24(3):550-557.
(
|
| [29] |
柯森繁, 金志军, 李志敏, 等. 我国8个水电站15种过鱼对象游泳能力研究[J]. 湖泊科学, 2022, 34(5):1608-1619.
(
|
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |
