PDF(1684 KB)
PDF(1684 KB)
PDF(1684 KB)
层间阳离子对膨润土膨胀应力应变的影响
Influence of Interlayer Cations on Swelling Stress and Strain of Bentonite
在核废料深地处置和垃圾填埋场工程中,作为缓冲和防渗层的压实膨润土与地下水盐溶液及垃圾渗滤液相互作用可诱发膨润土层间阳离子发生改变,进而导致其膨胀性和密封性能演变。为了分析层间阳离子对压实膨润土宏观膨胀特性的影响规律和机制,对不同阳离子基膨润土开展膨胀变形和膨胀力试验,并进行X射线衍射和扫描电镜观测。膨胀试验结果表明:不同阳离子基膨润土的膨胀力呈现出Mg基土>Ca基土>Na基土>K基土的规律,而膨胀变形则表现为Na基土>K基土>Ca基土≈Mg基土;不同阳离子基膨润土的膨胀力与膨胀应变的发展速率与浸水时间之间呈现良好的线性变化规律。在体积受限的膨胀力试验中,Ca基与Mg基膨润土的层间膨胀(层间距)更大,而在无约束的膨胀变形过程,Na基膨润土的渗透膨胀更强烈。层间阳离子的水化能及其与晶层间的相互作用控制着压实膨润土吸水膨胀过程中微观结构演变和宏观膨胀势的显现。试验研究结果可为相关工程设计及安全评估提供参考。
[Objective] Compacted bentonite is a critical buffer material for the deep geological disposal of nuclear waste and landfill engineering. Its swelling characteristics are directly affected by cation exchange with groundwater or landfill leachate. While existing research has clarified cation-related hydration and swelling mechanisms in bentonite powder or via molecular dynamics simulations, studies on the influence of interlayer cations on compacted samples remain limited. This study aims to fill this gap by investigating the influence of interlayer cations on the macroscopic swelling behavior of compacted bentonite, thereby providing technical support for engineering design and safety assessment. [Methods] The test material was bentonite from Shouguang, Shandong Province, containing a montmorillonite content exceeding 95% and exhibiting excellent swelling and adsorption properties. Four types of homoionic bentonite (Na-based, K-based, Ca-based, Mg-based) were prepared via cation exchange by mixing bentonite with 1 mol/L solutions of NaCl, KCl, CaCl2, or MgCl2. The samples were compacted to a dry density of 1.1 g/cm3 with an initial moisture content of 20%. A self-developed integrated consolidation-swelling device was used for volume-constrained swelling pressure tests and unconfined swelling strain tests. Complementary characterizations included X-ray diffraction (XRD) to measure interlayer spacing (d001) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to observe microstructural changes. [Results] The final swelling pressure of the four types of homoionic bentonite followed a distinct hierarchy: Mg-based (5.98 MPa) > Ca-based (5.79 MPa) > Na-based (4.49 MPa) > K-based (3.61 MPa). Swelling pressure curves exhibited a “rise-decline-stabilization” trend: rapid growth occurred within 0-2 h, with Mg/Ca-based samples peaking at 6.21 MPa and 5.18 MPa, respectively, followed by a slight decline due to aggregate splitting and pore filling, and finally stabilizing after 18 h. Na/K-based samples stabilized after 22 h without an early decline. The ratio of time to swelling pressure showed a strong linear correlation with time. This correlation enabled the prediction of the maximum swelling pressure, and the predicted values were highly consistent with the measured values. For swelling strain, the order was Na-based (72.7%) > K-based (51.5%) > Ca-based (47.0%) ≈ Mg-based (48.7%). Swelling strain curves exhibited three stages: slow growth (0-0.06 h, clay particle hydration), rapid growth (0.06-10 h, dominant interlayer swelling), and stabilization. The swelling strain of Mg/Ca-based samples stabilized faster than that of Na/K-based ones. The ratio of time to swelling strain also showed excellent linearity with time, and the reciprocal of slope could be used to predict the maximum strain. XRD results showed that after swelling pressure tests, Mg/Ca-based samples had larger interlayer spacings (18.62 Å/18.10 Å, 3 layers of interlayer water) than Na/K-based ones (15.63 Å/15.39 Å, 2 layers). After swelling strain tests, Na/K-based samples adsorbed over 4 layers of water, resulting in larger spacings (23.68 Å/20.98 Å). SEM images revealed that Na/K-based samples had thin, curled lamellar aggregates with uniform pores, while Ca/Mg-based samples had thicker aggregates and more macropores. [Conclusion] Interlayer cations regulate the macroscopic swelling behavior of compacted bentonite through their hydration energy and interaction with the crystal layers. Divalent cations (Ca2+ and Mg2+) have higher hydration energy than monovalent cations (Na+ and K+), enabling stronger interlayer swelling under volume-constrained conditions and consequently resulting in higher swelling pressure. The minimum swelling pressure recorded for K-based bentonite stems from the matching of its ionic radius with the montmorillonite crystal cavity, which promotes the formation of stable interlayer structures. Under unconfined conditions, monovalent cations (Na+ and K+) have weaker interaction with the crystal layers, allowing more interlayer water adsorption and intense osmotic expansion. This accounts for the larger swelling strain of Na- and K- based samples. The development rates of swelling pressure and strain have a good linear relationship with immersion time, and the proposed empirical formulas provide a reliable tool for predicting maximum swelling characteristics. Microstructural evolution (aggregate splitting and pore distribution) is closely linked to interlayer cation type, which further determines macroscopic performance. The findings of this study highlight the significant effect of interlayer cations and emphasize the necessity of considering interlayer cation composition of bentonite-based barriers. The differences in the macroscopic swelling pressure and swelling strain of different cationic bentonites should be given high priority in relevant engineering design and evaluation.
压实膨润土 / 层间阳离子 / 膨胀力 / 膨胀应变 / 微观结构
compacted bentonite / interlayer cation / swelling pressure / swelling strain / microstructure
| [1] |
刘樟荣, 崔玉军, 叶为民, 等. 缓冲/回填材料: 膨润土颗粒及其混合物研究进展[J]. 岩土工程学报, 2020, 42(8): 1401-1410.
(
|
| [2] |
鞠建英. 防渗膨润土的研究及其在工程中的应用[J]. 水利水电科技进展, 2000, 20(5): 27-29, 63.
(
|
| [3] |
李裕诚, 陈永贵, 刘丽, 等. 高压实膨润土多尺度膨胀力特性研究进展[J]. 岩土工程学报, 2024, 46(11):2457-2464.
(
|
| [4] |
胡桂阳, 刘清秉, 许振浩, 等. 击实状态下膨润土加砂混合物膨胀特性及影响因素[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2020, 37(1):100-107.
膨润土加砂混合物是进行核废料深埋处置的理想缓冲回填材料,其膨胀变形特性是评价处置库屏障体系的重要参数。以不同掺砂率下的高庙子钠基膨润土为研究对象,在室内分别开展了击实试验、有荷膨胀率试验、膨胀力试验,重点研究其膨胀变形,并通过微观电镜扫描分析其膨胀特性的影响因素。试验结果表明:随着掺砂率的增加,膨润土加砂混合物的最大干密度也会增大,且击实曲线从相对平缓、开阔逐渐向陡立和狭窄发展,即当掺砂率增加时,混合物干密度梯度变化值受含水率的影响显著;混合物的膨胀过程大致分为3个阶段,即快速膨胀阶段、减速膨胀阶段和缓慢膨胀阶段,有荷膨胀率δ<sub>ep</sub>与时间的关系可采用双曲线关系拟合,而最大膨胀力与掺砂率的关系可采用指数关系拟合;基于不同初始状态下的微观结构,综合分析得出单位体积的蒙脱石含量和颗粒结构是影响其膨胀特性的根本因素。
(
The mixture of bentonite and sand is an ideal buffer material for deep landfill disposal of nuclear waste. The swelling deformation of bentonite-sand mixture is an important parameter in evaluating the barrier system of disposal repository engineering. In this investigation, the swelling deformation of sodium bentonite mixed with sand was examined through compaction tests, loaded expansion ratio tests, and expansive force tests. Furthermore, the influencing factors on expansive deformation were analyzed in terms of microstructure via scanning electron microscopy. Results show that with the increase of sand dosage, the maximum dry density of bentonite-sand mixture also increases; also the compaction curve gradually evolves from being relatively flat and open to vertical and narrow, which means that the variation of dry density gradient of the mixture is affected markedly by moisture content. The expansion process of the mixture, in terms of the time curve, can be divided into three stages: the rapidly expanding stage, the decelerated expanding stage, and slowly expanding stage. Moreover, the relation between loaded expansive rate δ and time can be fitted by hyperbola; the relation between maximum expanding force and sand dosage follows exponential distribution. The microstructure of samples under different compacted conditions obtained from scanning electron microscope demonstrated that montmorillonite content of unit volume and microstructure are the fundamental factors influencing the expansion of bentonite-sand mixture.
|
| [5] |
潘东玥, 王琼, 苏薇, 等. 温度影响的吸力循环过程GMZ膨润土持水特征[J]. 哈尔滨工业大学学报, 2024, 56(11):36-44.
(
|
| [6] |
童艳梅, 张虎元, 李雪婷, 等. 碱性溶液对高庙子膨润土缓冲性能的影响[J]. 世界核地质科学, 2023, 40(增刊1):607-613.
(
|
| [7] |
于海文, 马田田, 韦昌富, 等. 阳离子交换量和盐溶液浓度对膨润土膨胀变形的影响[J]. 岩土力学, 2023, 44(9): 2603-2610.
(
|
| [8] |
|
| [9] |
|
| [10] |
项国圣, 方圆, 徐永福. 阳离子交换对高庙子钠基膨润土膨胀性能的影响[J]. 浙江大学学报(工学版), 2017, 51(5): 931-936.
(
|
| [11] |
|
| [12] |
|
| [13] |
|
| [14] |
|
| [15] |
王平全. 粘土表面结合水定量分析及水合机制研究[D]. 成都: 西南石油学院, 2001.
(
|
| [16] |
|
| [17] |
Expansion properties often homoionic smectites that differed in amount and location of layer charge were examined by X-ray powder diffraction analysis at various relative humidities, or after glycerol or ethylene glycol solvations. Except for K-samples with glycerol solvation, and Na- and Ca-samples with ethylene glycol, differences in the basal spacings are observed in samples having similar layer charge. These results show that the basal spacings are larger when the layer charge is located in octahedral sites than when it is in tetrahedral sites. This suggests that expansion is due to the combined effects of the charge location and amount.
|
| [18] |
|
| [19] |
|
| [20] |
The osmotic character of long-range interlamellar swelling in smectite clays is widely accepted and has been evidenced in the interlayer space by X-ray diffraction. Such a behavior in mesopores was not experimentally confirmed until the determination of the mesopore size distribution in Na-montmorillonite prepared from MX80 bentonite using thermoporometry experiments. This is confirmed here for other montmorillonite samples where the interlayer cations are alkaline and Ca(2+) cations. The nature of the interlayer cation is found as strongly influencing the behavior of the size and the swelling of mesopores. These results are supported by the BJH (Barrett, Joyner and Halenda) pore radius values issued from the nitrogen adsorption-desorption isotherms at the dry state. Thermoporometry results as a function of relative humidity ranging from 11% to 97% have shown an evolution of the mesopore sizes for a purified Na-montmorillonite. New thermoporometry data are presented in this article and confirm that the interparticle spaces in K-, Cs-, or Ca-montmorillonites are not strongly modified for all the range of relative humidity: the swelling is not observed or is strongly limited. It appears in contrast that only Li- and Na-montmorillonites undergo a mesopore swelling, distinct from the interlayer swelling. More generally, our results confirm the possibility to use thermoporometry or differential scanning calorimetry to study the structure and the evolution of swelling materials in wetting conditions such as natural clays or biological cells. In this paper, we describe the different key steps of the hydration of swelling clays such as montmorillonites saturated with alkaline cations. Using thermoporometry results combined with X-ray diffraction data, we distinguish the evolution of the porosity at the two different scales and propose a sequence of hydration dependent on the interlayer cation. From this study, it is shown that the interlayer spaces are not completely filled when the mesopores start to fill up. This implies that the swelling observed in the mesopores for Li and Na samples is due to an osmotic swelling. For the other samples, it is difficult to conclude definitively. Furthermore, we determine the different proportion of water (interlayer water and mesopore water) present in our samples by the original combination of (1) X-ray diffraction data, (2) the pore size distribution obtained by thermoporometry, and (3) recent adsorption isotherm results. It is found that the interlayer space is never completely filled by water at the studied relative humidity values for all samples except for the Cs sample.
|
| [21] |
|
| [22] |
The effects of temperature on the swelling properties of smectites are important for a variety of different geological conditions, but studies on this topic have been rather limited. The purpose of this study was to investigate the swelling behavior of Na- and Ca-montmorillonite at various temperatures greater than room temperature, up to 150°C, using in situ X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis. A sample chamber was designed, the temperature and humidity of which were controlled precisely, for environmental in situ measurements. The XRD measurements were performed at small relative humidity (RH) intervals for precise observation of the swelling behavior.
|
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |