基于响应面法的花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土配合比优化设计

何建进, 游允越, 俞钦, 郑伟, 张挺

长江科学院院报 ›› 2026, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (2) : 174-180.

PDF(5204 KB)
PDF(5204 KB)
长江科学院院报 ›› 2026, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (2) : 174-180. DOI: 10.11988/ckyyb.20241234
水工结构与材料

基于响应面法的花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土配合比优化设计

作者信息 +

Optimization Design of the Mix Proportion of Granite Aggregate Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete Based on Response Surface Methodology

Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

为实现花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土配合比优化设计,采用Box-Behnken响应面法进行试验设计,构建响应面回归模型,研究砂率、填料用量和油石比对花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土性能(孔隙率、稳定度、流值)的影响,并确定最优配合比。结果表明:砂率、油石比、砂率和油石比的交互作用对稳定度、流值和孔隙率的影响显著,填料用量、填料与油石比的交互作用影响较小;经响应面优化,花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土的最优配合比为砂率33%、油石比7.1%、填料用量12.5%。该回归模型有效且可信度高,可用于试验结果分析,并可为花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土配合比优化设计提供参考。

Abstract

[Objective] The adhesion problem between acidic aggregates and asphalt is a key issue in the application of acidic aggregates in hydraulic asphalt concrete. For hydraulic structures, the mix design of hydraulic asphalt concrete incorporating acidic aggregates modified with anti-stripping agents is not entirely the same as that used in road engineering. This study aims to investigate, under a constant gradation index, the individual effects of the proportion of coarse and fine aggregates, as well as their interaction effects with asphalt-aggregate ratio and filler content, on the performance of anti-stripping-agent-modified hydraulic asphalt concrete with granite aggregates, and to optimize the mix proportion design of granite aggregate hydraulic asphalt concrete. [Methods] A Box-Behnken response surface methodology was employed for experimental design. Air voids, flow value, and stability were selected as response variables to establish response surface regression models. The effects of asphalt-aggregate ratio, filler content, and sand ratio, as well as their single and interaction effects on the response values, were analyzed to determine the optimal mix proportion. Meanwhile, water stability tests were conducted to verify the performance. [Results] (1) The mix proportion design of granite hydraulic asphalt concrete was optimized using response surface methodology, and the established quadratic regression equations were able to well describe the relationships among sand ratio, asphalt-aggregate ratio, filler content, and air voids, stability, and flow value. Analysis of variance and significance tests indicated that the model was effective and reliable, with high credibility. (2) Response surface analysis showed that the order of influence on the air voids of granite hydraulic asphalt concrete was asphalt-aggregate ratio>sand ratio>filler content; the order of influence on stability was sand ratio > asphalt-aggregate ratio > filler content; and the order of influence on flow value was sand ratio > asphalt-aggregate ratio > filler content. (3) The three-dimensional distribution of the water stability coefficient indicated that a relatively high water stability coefficient was obtained in the region where the sand ratio ≤ 36%, filler content ≤13.5%, and asphalt-aggregate ratio ≥6.8%. (4) The optimized mix design parameters of granite hydraulic asphalt concrete were a sand ratio of 33%, an asphalt-aggregate ratio of 7.1%, and a filler content of 12.5%. [Conclusion] The experimental results confirm that this mix proportion exhibits good performance and can provide a reference for the optimization design of granite hydraulic asphalt concrete mix proportions in practical engineering.

关键词

响应面方法 / 水工沥青混凝土 / 花岗岩骨料 / 配合比优化

Key words

response surface methodology / hydraulic asphalt concrete / granite aggregate / mix proportion optimization

引用本文

导出引用
何建进, 游允越, 俞钦, . 基于响应面法的花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土配合比优化设计[J]. 长江科学院院报. 2026, 43(2): 174-180 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20241234
HE Jian-jin, YOU Yun-yue, YU Qin, et al. Optimization Design of the Mix Proportion of Granite Aggregate Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete Based on Response Surface Methodology[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute. 2026, 43(2): 174-180 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20241234
中图分类号: TV431.5   

参考文献

[1]
DONG J, DING Y, LIU Y, et al. Tensile Test and Discrete Element Study on Recycled Aggregate Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2024, 450: 138538.
[2]
HE J, LU J, YANG W, et al. Fracture Performance and Cracking Mechanism of Large-particle Size Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete at Different Temperatures[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 2024, 311: 110530.
[3]
黄振伟, 雷明, 张玮鹏. 西藏拉洛水利枢纽沥青混凝土骨料质量评价及料场比选[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2020, 37(9):149-153,159.
摘要
沥青混凝土心墙是土石坝的重要结构,骨料、填料等原材料质量对心墙抗渗性、耐久性及适应变形的能力具有决定性影响。以位于西藏自治区日喀则市的拉洛水利枢纽工程为例,初拟2处沥青混凝土人工骨料石料场以资比选,进行了各项质量参数的试验检测,综合考虑各种因素后选定了运距虽然相对较远但质量更好的卡贡灰岩石料场作为料源,确保高原、高寒、高海拔地区沥青混凝土心墙坝的安全。同时,分析、讨论了沥青混凝土用人工骨料原材料岩石质量评价时应注意的若干问题,并提出了解决问题的意见和建议,可供下一步修订相关标准时参考。
(HUANG Zhen-wei, LEI Ming, ZHANG Wei-peng. Quality Evaluation of Asphalt Concrete Aggregate and Comparison and Selection of Material Yard for Laluo Water Conservancy Project in Tibet[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2020, 37(9): 149-153, 159.(in Chinese))
Asphalt concrete core wall is an important structure of earth rock dam. The quality of raw materials such as aggregate and filler has a decisive influence on the impermeability, durability and deformation adaptability of the core wall. With Laluo water conservancy project in Rikaze city of Tibet Autonomous Region as an example, we compared two artificial aggregate quarries for the asphalt concrete through testing and inpection of multiple quality parameters. After comprehensive consideration of various factors, we selet Kagong limestone yard which is more distant yet boasts better rock quality as the material source to ensure the safety of asphalt concrete core dam in plateau, cold and high altitude areas. Moreover, we analyze and discusse some problems that should be paid attention to in the quality evaluation of raw materials of artificial aggregate for asphalt concrete, and put forward some suggestions to solve the problems for reference in the revision of relevant standards.
[4]
王富强, 阳利君, 莫品疆. 提高花岗岩沥青混合料水稳定性试验研究[J]. 公路, 2020, 65(11): 328-330.
(WANG Fu-qiang, YANG Li-jun, MO Pin-jiang. Experimental Study on Improving Water Stability of Granite Asphalt Mixture[J]. Highway, 2020, 65(11): 328-330.(in Chinese))
[5]
王伟, 罗蓉, 蒋兵, 等. 酸性安山岩集料黏附性能改善研究[J]. 武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版), 2021, 45(6):1158-1162.
(WANG Wei, LUO Rong, JIANG Bing, et al. Study on Improving Adhesion Performance of Acid Andesite Aggregate[J]. Journal of Wuhan University of Technology (Transportation Science & Engineering), 2021, 45(6): 1158-1162.(in Chinese))
[6]
DAN H, LIU X, CHEN J. Multi-scale Investigation on Water Stability and Anti-aging Performance of Granite Asphalt Mixture Modified with Composite Anti-stripping Agents[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2024, 453: 139031.
[7]
刘杰, 郭海鹏, 李刚. 不同配合比参数对沥青混凝土低温抗裂性能的影响[J]. 水电能源科学, 2019, 37(6):118-120.
(LIU Jie, GUO Hai-peng, LI Gang. Influence of Different Mix Parameters on Behaviors of Asphalt Concrete under Low Temperature[J]. Water Resources and Power, 2019, 37(6): 118-120.(in Chinese))
[8]
闫小虎, 姚新华, 王晓军, 等. 土石坝沥青混凝土心墙材料配合比试验研究[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2017, 34(6): 143-148.
摘要
传统观念认为水工沥青混凝土防渗结构中,碱性骨料可以与沥青中的表面活性物质产生化学吸附,有很好的黏附性;酸性骨料与沥青主要是物理吸附作用,与沥青的黏附性和耐久性无法保证,在长期浸水作用下,沥青膜易被水逐渐置换而从骨料表面剥离,从而导致结构破坏。奴尔水利枢纽工程坝址区内有丰富的酸性天然砂砾石料,距坝址较近,便于开采,但其附近没有碱性骨料料场。依托奴尔水利枢纽工程,采用人工灰岩骨料及天然砂砾料2种骨料,进行了室内沥青混凝土配合比性能试验研究,提出了级配指数r=0.40、填料F=12%、人工灰岩骨料沥青含量B=6.9%和天然砂砾石骨料沥青含量B=6.0%优选配合比,供设计参考。
(YAN Xiao-hu, YAO Xin-hua, WANG Xiao-jun, et al. Experimental Research on Mix Proportion of Asphaltic Concrete Core Material in Earth-rock Dams[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2017, 34(6): 143-148.(in Chinese))
In impervious structures such as hydraulic asphaltic concrete, alkaline aggregate is generally considered to be of good adhesion resulted from the chemisorption between alkaline aggregate and surface active materials of asphalt; while acidic aggregate could lead to structural damage as asphalt film is easily replaced by water and detached from aggregate under long-term water immersion because the physical adsorption could not guarantee the adhesion and durability of asphalt. By using artificial limestone and natural gravel aggregates, laboratory tests were conducted to research the mix proportion of hydraulic asphalt concrete for Nuer water control project in Xinjiang, which has rich natural acidic gravel aggregate near the dam site but no alkaline aggregate nearby. Optimization of mix proportion is proposed as follows gradation index r=0.40, filler content F=12%, asphalt content B=6.9% for concrete with artificial limestone aggregates, and B=6.0% for concrete with natural gravel aggregates.
[9]
王丽峰. 酸性骨料沥青混凝土配合比优选[J]. 东北水利水电, 2023, 41(12):23-27,71.
(WANG Li-feng. Acid Aggregate Asphalt Concrete Mix Ratio Optimization[J]. Water Resources & Hydropower of Northeast China, 2023, 41(12): 23-27, 71.(in Chinese))
[10]
陈晨, 王亚萍, 焦凯, 等. 花岗岩骨料水工沥青混凝土面板关键性能研究[J]. 水资源与水工程学报, 2023, 34(2):149-156.
(CHEN Chen, WANG Ya-ping, JIAO Kai, et al. Key Properties of Hydraulic Granite Asphalt Concrete Panels[J]. Journal of Water Resources and Water Engineering, 2023, 34(2): 149-156.(in Chinese))
[11]
刘继汉. 考虑细骨料率的水工沥青混凝土配合比优化设计研究[D]. 西安: 西安理工大学, 2023.
(LIU Ji-han. Research on Optimal Design of Mix Ratio of Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete Considering Fine Aggregate Ratio[D]. Xi’an: Xi’an University of Technology, 2023.(in Chinese))
[12]
LI Y, LIU J, LIU Y, et al. Aggregate Grading Design of Skeleton Dense Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2023, 365: 130031.
[13]
LI Y, LI Y, LIU J, et al. Optimization of Some Properties of Hydraulic Asphalt Concrete Mix Using RSM and NSGA-II[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2024, 438:137317.
[14]
程培峰, 王洋弘历, 李艺铭, 等. 基于响应面法的半柔性路面材料低温性能研究[J]. 功能材料, 2024, 55(6): 6118-6127.
摘要
为提高半柔性路面材料(SFPM)低温抗裂性能,采用橡胶粉与硅烷偶联剂对水泥砂浆进行改性,制备复合半柔性路面材料(R&S-SFPM)。基于响应面分析法以劈裂抗拉强度、抗弯拉强度、最大弯拉应变、弯曲蠕变速率以及平均线收缩系数作为评价指标分析胶粉目数、掺量及硅烷偶联剂用量对SFPM低温性能的影响,并确定了可获得最优低温性能表现的R&S-SFPM掺配比例。结果表明:橡胶粉可提高SFPM的应力松弛能力,使其具有更好的柔韧性;硅烷偶联剂可提高SFPM力学强度。此外,橡胶粉及硅烷偶联剂掺量、胶粉目数均对SFPM低温性能改善效果有较大影响。当胶粉目数为60目、掺量为14%,硅烷偶联剂用量为0.72%时,R&S-SFPM综合低温效果最佳;与普通半柔性路面材料(O-SFPM)相比,R&S-SFPM的劈裂抗拉强度、抗弯拉强度、最大弯拉应变以及弯曲蠕变速率分别提高23.7%、7.6%、29.9%和15.2%。
(CHENG Pei-feng, WANG Yanghongli, LI Yi-ming, et al. Study on Low Temperature Performance of Semi-flexible-Pavement Materials Based on Response Surface Method[J]. Journal of Functional Materials, 2024, 55(6): 6118-6127.(in Chinese))
[15]
RAZA M S, SHARMA S K. Optimizing Porous Asphalt Mix Design for Permeability and Air Voids Using Response Surface Methodology and Artificial Neural Networks[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2024, 442: 137513.
[16]
朱大章, 孙晓宇, 吕伟民, 等. 非胺类沥青抗剥落剂的制备及性能[J]. 建筑材料学报, 2005, 8(5):474-479.
(ZHU Da-zhang, SUN Xiao-yu, Wei-min, et al. Preparation and Performance of a Novel Asphalt Antistripping Agent Containing No Amines[J]. Journal of Building Materials, 2005, 8(5): 474-479.(in Chinese))

编辑: 任坤杰
PDF(5204 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

段落导航
相关文章

/