PDF(6384 KB)
PDF(6384 KB)
PDF(6384 KB)
长距离重力流加压联合输水系统水锤防护数值模拟
Numerical Simulation and Optimization of Water Hammer Protection Schemes for Long-Distance Gravity-Pressurized Water Conveyance Systems
长距离重力流输水系统在大流量输水期间需开启首部泵站加压供水,形成重力流加压联合输水,如遇事故停泵极易引起管线内水柱分离,产生弥合水锤威胁工程安全。采用特征线法对空气阀、空气阀+末端阀联合、空气阀+末端阀+溢流管联合、空气阀+空气阀调压室联合4种水锤防护方案开展水锤数值模拟。结果表明:对长距离重力流加压联合输水系统,利用末端阀关闭形成增压波无法有效改善管内负压效果,还可能带来管内最大压力超标问题;利用调压管和空气阀组合的空气阀调压室兼顾了补水和补气功能,与空气阀联合防护对于管内正、负压均有良好的防护效果,可作为长距离重力流加压输水系统的首选防护手段。
[Objective] When the water level difference between the upstream and downstream of a long-distance gravitational water conveyance system is small, gravity flow alone cannot ensure the required design flow rate. In such cases, the intake pumping station must be activated during high-flow conveyance periods to provide pressurized supply, forming a combined gravity and pressurized flow system. The hydraulic characteristics of such systems are more complex than those of pure gravity-driven systems. Accidental pump shutdowns can easily induce water column separation in the pipeline, leading to water hammer upon rejoining that poses a significant threat to project safety. [Methods] To address this issue, this study employed the method of characteristic curve to conduct one-dimensional numerical simulations of transient hydraulic processes for four water hammer protection schemes: (1) air valve, (2) air valve + terminal valve, (3) air valve + terminal valve + overflow pipe, and (4) air valve + air valve surge chamber. [Results] In long-distance gravity-pressurized water conveyance systems where the upstream elevation was higher than that of the downstream, accidental pump shutdowns without any protective measures would generate decompression waves that caused extreme negative pressure and water column separation inside the pipeline. The subsequent compression wave reflected from the downstream outlet reservoir would cause the separated water column to rejoin, potentially resulting in pipe rupture. Therefore, effective protective measures must be adopted to eliminate extreme negative pressure in the pipeline. When using an air valve alone for water hammer protection, the minimum pressure within the pipeline was effectively increased, but the range of protection was limited. In the air valve + terminal valve scheme, the compression wave generated by the closure of the terminal valve failed to effectively mitigate the negative pressure and may even result in excessive maximum pressure due to poor closure regulation of the terminal valve. Adding an overflow pipe to this combined scheme effectively reduced the maximum pressure in the pipeline. However, since the overflow pipe reflected part of the compression wave generated by the terminal valve closure, it had an adverse effect on negative pressure protection. [Conclusions] The air valve surge chamber, combining a surge pipe and an air valve with both water and air compensation functions, is used in combination with an air valve to form a protection scheme that effectively controls both positive and negative pressures in the pipeline. This solution achieves balance between engineering safety and cost-efficiency, making it the preferred protective measure for long-distance gravity-pressurized water conveyance systems.
重力流 / 停泵水锤 / 水柱分离 / 空气阀 / 空气阀调压室
gravity flow / pump shutdown water hammer / water column separation / air valve / air valve surge chamber
| [1] |
曾敏, 谢杰, 黄伟, 等. 长距离负扬程加压泵站调水工程水力控制方式探讨[J]. 长江科学院院报, 2024, 41(9):93-97,113.
事故掉电引发的停泵水锤是泵站调水工程安全运行最主要的威胁之一,而对于下游水位低于上游水位的长距离负扬程加压泵站调水工程而言,事故停泵易造成管道拉空,负水锤防护难度较大,因此,针对其停泵工况的水力控制研究十分重要。以某长距离负扬程泵站调水工程为例,模拟计算了事故停泵、阀门拒动这一控制性工况下的水力过渡过程,并对比分析了空气罐、空气阀与空气阀联合空气阀调压室3种水力控制方案的水锤防护效果。结果表明:对于长距离负扬程加压泵站调水系统而言,当采用空气罐的水力控制方式时,所需的空气罐体积较大,投资高昂;当单纯采用空气阀的水力控制方式时,难以有效解决管道局部高点处负压较大的问题,仍可能诱发弥合性水锤;当将部分空气阀附加一根短管组合成空气阀调压室后,能够有效控制管内负压。空气阀与空气阀调压室联合防护是一种十分经济且有效的水锤防护方案,可为这类负扬程加压调水工程的水力控制方式选取提供参考。
(
The pump-stopping water hammer caused by accidental power failure is one of the main threats to the safe operation of pump station project. For long-distance negative-lift pump station (LDNLPS) with downstream water level lower than upstream water level, accidental pump stop can easily cause pipeline emptying, which makes it challenging to protect against negative water hammer. It is crucial to investigate hydraulic control measures for pump stop conditions. Taking a LDNLPS as a case study, we simulated the hydraulic transients under accidental pump stop and valve rejection conditions. We compared and analyzed the water hammer protection effects of three hydraulic control schemes: air tank, air valve, and combination of air valve with air-valve surge chamber. The results indicate that using air tank requires large volume and high investment costs; air valve alone struggles to address the large negative pressure at local high points of the pipeline and may still induce bridging water hammer. Conversely, combining some air valves with short pipes to form air valve surge chamber effectively controls the negative pressure in the pipeline. In conclusion, the combination of air valve with air-valve surge chamber is economical and effective in protecting against water hammer, hence offering a viable solution for hydraulic control in similar LDNLPS projects. |
| [2] |
GB 50015—2019, 建筑给水排水设计标准[S]. 北京: 中国计划出版社, 2019.
(GB 50015—2019, Standard for Design of Building Water Supply and Drainage[S]. Beijing: China Planning Press, 2019. (in Chinese))
|
| [3] |
黄毅, 陈锋. 长距离输水工程末端关阀方式对水锤防护的影响[J]. 人民长江, 2018, 49(5): 70-73.
(
|
| [4] |
|
| [5] |
刘君, 段宏江, 兰刚, 等. 有局部高点的长距离高扬程输水系统水锤防护研究[J]. 给水排水, 2014, 50(增刊1): 359-362.
(
|
| [6] |
薛松, 张石磊, 李进平, 等. 超长重力流输水系统水锤防护的顶部联通溢流式调压塔方案研究[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2022(7): 158-163,174.
提出一种针对超长重力流输水系统水锤防护的多调压塔方案。该方案利用一种新型的顶部联通溢流式调压塔将长系统分隔成多个短系统,有效抑制水锤压强上升并防止爆管事故蔓延。给出了该方案的设计原则,其中关键是确定顶部联通溢流式调压塔的下溢堰和外溢堰高程:管线末端设置将波动流量溢向下游水库的调压塔,其溢流堰高程控制全线水力坡降线;中部调压塔因地形地势间隔设置,其下溢堰高程按系统稳定运行时有足够输水能力确定,外溢堰高程按过渡过程中不外溢或少量外溢确定。结合工程实例,证明该方案具有良好的水锤防护效果,可为类似工程提供参考。
(
A water hammer protection scheme that combines multiple surge towers for super-long gravitational water conveyance system is proposed. The surge towers are a new specific overflow type that closes flow in its bottom and connects flow in its top, which can suppress water hammer pressure and divide the long system to several sections for preventing the spread of pipe burst accidents. The design principle of the scheme is given, in which the key is to determine the crest elevations of the downstream overflow weir and outer overflow weir of the surge tower. A surge tower should be set at the end of the pipeline, and there should be a reservoir nearby to discharge the overflow water; the crest elevations of the outer overflow weirs of this tower is the controlling parameter of the hydraulic gradeline of the system; several towers in the middle of the system should be set according to landform conditions; the crest elevations of the downstream overflow weirs of these towers in the system middle are determined to ensure adequate flow capacity; the crest elevations of the outer overflow weirs of these towers are selected to prevent or reduce overflows out of the system in transient conditions. The analysis combined with an engineering example shows that the scheme can significantly decrease water hammer pressure along the system and is an appropriate candidate for similar projects. |
| [7] |
仇为鑫, 张健, 吴旭敏, 等. 空气阀在多水源高扬程供水工程中的水锤防护研究[J]. 灌溉排水学报, 2022, 41(2):140-146.
(
|
| [8] |
杨开林. 控制输水管道瞬态液柱分离的空气阀调压室[J]. 水利学报, 2011, 42(7):805-811.
(
|
| [9] |
杨开林. 电站与泵站中的水力瞬变及调节[M]. 北京: 中国水利水电出版社, 2000.
(
|
| [10] |
祖子豪. 长距离低落差引调水工程水力安全控制研究[D]. 南昌: 南昌大学, 2024.
(
|
| [11] |
|
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |