对《长江科学院院报》近年来影响因子的分析与思考

姜小兰; 刘运飞

doi:10.11988/ckyyb.20150553

PDF(1049 KB)

长江科学院院报 ›› 2015, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (12) : 150-154. DOI: 10.11988/ckyyb.20150553

读者·作者·编者

对《长江科学院院报》近年来影响因子的分析与思考

姜小兰,刘运飞

作者信息 +

Analysis and Considerations on the Impact Factor of Journal of YangtzeRiver Scientific Research Institute in Recent Years

JIANG Xiao-lan,LIU Yun-fei

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

从《长江科学院院报》(简称《院报》)的定位和报道内容出发,首先分析了2009—2013年该刊在知网数据库中的影响因子主要指标,明确了本刊在全国科技期刊、水利工程类期刊中所处的位置;其次,对影响《院报》影响因子的几个因素(发文量的控制、优秀稿件的来源、综述性与热点性及学术前沿性论文的报道、论文报道时差)进行了全面分析;同时对期刊影响因子评价体系提出了几点看法:既存在客观性与科学性,也存在局限性与盲目性;并且提出了学术期刊其核心使命是为学术研究服务的,期刊本质是学术成果登载的载体,无论是传统纸质期刊,还是网络时代的数字期刊,其内容永远是期刊的核心,没有高质量论文内容,就谈不上学术影响;最后,认为不要对影响因子盲目崇拜,每一本学术期刊都有自己的独特学术风格,《院报》应立足于长江,凸显长江的水资源开发与利用、水环境治理与生态保护、水利工程建设与管理等方面的科学问题,在保证期刊质量的同时,形成“长江特色”才是《院报》今后的发展之路。

Abstract

According to the position and content of Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute (hereafter referred to as the Journal),we recognized its status among Chinese scientific journals and hydraulic journals by analysing the main indicators of its impact factor in CNKI database.Moreover,we analysed several parameters which affect the impact factor, including control for the amount of published papers,the sources of excellent papers,the publishing of reviews,hotspots and academic frontiers,as well as time difference of receiving and publishing.We also proposed that the evaluation system of impact factor is objective and scientific,but sometimes partial and sightless.Furthermore,the mission of academic journal is to serve for academic research,which means that academic content is the essence of journals,no matter traditional papery journals or digital journals in network times.Without outstanding papers, journals will be like water without a source,and tree without roots,much less academic impact.Finally,we emphasized it is blind to worship impact factors,for each academic journal should have its individual academic characteristics.As for the Journal,the essential content and academic style of it is to highlight the exploitation,regulation,protection and management of the Yangtze River.In the future,on the premise of improving papers quality,we should gradually develop a unique academic feature by specializing in the Yangtze River.

导出引用

姜小兰,刘运飞. 对《长江科学院院报》近年来影响因子的分析与思考[J]. 长江科学院院报. 2015, 32(12): 150-154 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20150553

JIANG Xiao-lan,LIU Yun-fei. Analysis and Considerations on the Impact Factor of Journal of YangtzeRiver Scientific Research Institute in Recent Years[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute. 2015, 32(12): 150-154 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20150553

中图分类号： G236 G237.5

参考文献

[1] 陈绍选,姜小兰,刘运飞.《长江科学院院报》创刊30周年回顾与展望[J].长江科学院院报,2014,31(10):63-67,123.(CHEN Shao-xuan,JIANG Xiao-lan,LIU Yun-fei.Review and Prospect on the 30th Anniversary of Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute[J].Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute,2014,31(10):63-67,123.(in Chinese))
[2] 史庆华.影响因子评价专业学术期刊的科学性与局限性[J].现代情报,2006,(1):35-36.(SHI Qing-hua.Advantage Effects and Limitations of Impact Factor to Evaluate Academic Periodicals Quality[J].Journal of Modern Information,2006,(1):35-36.(in Chinese))
[3] 中国知网.影响因子年报[DB/OL].(2014-12-05)[2015-06-08].http:∥www.jif.cnki.net/Core/Journal/Default.aspx?pykm=CJKB.(CNKI.Annual of Impact Factors[DB/OL].(2014-12-05)[2015-06-08].http:∥www.jif.cnki.net/Core/Journal/Default.aspx?pykm=CJKB.(in Chinese))
[4] 中国科学文献计量评价研究中心,清华大学图书馆.中国学术期刊影响因子年报(自然科学与工程技术)[M].北京:《中国学术期刊(光盘版)》电子杂志社有限公司,2009—2014.(Research Center for Bibliometrics and Chinese Science Evaluation,Tsinghua University Library.Annual Report for Impact Factors of Chinese Academic Journals(Natural Science)[M].Beijing:China Academic Journal (CD) Publishing House,2009—2014.(in Chinese))
[5] 盛丽娜.论医学期刊的学术影响力对论文被引频次的影响[J].科技情报开发与经济,2014,(8):119-122.(SHENG Li-na.Impact of Academic Influence for Medical Journal on Cited Paper Frequency[J].Sci-tech Information Development & Economy,2014,(8):119-122.(in Chinese))
[6] 颜维琦.“以刊论文”何时休？[N].光明日报,2014-03-03(10).(YAN Wei-qi.When Will the Situation of Judging Articles by Journal Published End?[N].Guangming Daily,2014-03-03(10).(in Chinese))
[7] 周淑霞.影响因子在学术期刊质量上的作用[J].图书馆理论与实践,2010,(6):38-39.(ZHOU Shu-xia.In-fluence of Impact Factor on Quality of Academic Journals[J].Library Theory and Practice,2010,(6):38-39.(in Chinese))
[8] 沈思,张红英.影响因子在科技期刊学术评价中的作用[J].情报探索,2009,(8):7-9.(SHEN Si,ZHANG Hong-ying.The Roles of Impact Factors in Scientific Periodicals Academic Evaluation[J].Information Research,2009,(8):7-9.(in Chinese))
[9] 王玉霞,印莉娟.科技期刊影响因子的本质意义、表征意义及影响因素[J].编辑学报,2006,18(增):172-173.(WANG Yu-xia,YIN Li-juan.Significance and influencing Factors of Journals Impact Factor[J].Acta Editologica,2006,18(Sup.):172-173.(in Chinese))
[10]木易,刘云.迷信“期刊影响因子”给高等教育带来负面影响[J].合肥学院学报(社会科学版),2014,(3):9.(MU Yi,LIU Yun.Adverse Influence of Worshipping Impact Factor of Journal on Higher Education[J].Journal of Hefei University (Social Sciences),2014,(3):9.(in Chinese))